Heeding the political lessons of Glaciergate January 22, 2010Posted by honestclimate in Discussions.
Tags: climate change, Glaciergate, global warming
Heeding the political lessons of Glaciergate
The Australian, January 22, 2010
Governments must constantly question the science
THE UN’s admissions on Glaciergate are welcome, but the international body has sustained damage from its sloppiness in reporting climate change data. Its claim to speak as the authority on climate science is reduced now that its Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has been forced to back down over a claim that some Himalayan glaciers would probably disappear by 2035.
The IPCC’s statement yesterday that the “clear and well-established standards of evidence” had not been properly applied to the claim, is an attempt to put the best possible spin on a blunder that has reverberated around the world since it was revealed last weekend. In fact Glaciergate, in large part, is about an extraordinary reliance on a third-hand source – a news story published in New Scientist almost a decade before it was included in the IPCC’s fourth assessment report of 2007.
It doesn’t get much more humiliating than that for a body that has positioned itself as the global scientific authority on climate change.
Read the rest here